Family feud: Four brothers demand that an Indian tycoon in the US pay them Rs. 2,000 crore

By Bricksnwall | 2024-03-02

A business mogul was ordered to pay his brothers Rs 2,000 crore in damages and divide his Southern California property in a land dispute that dates back 21 years in Los Angeles. Real estate, trade, and diamonds were all factors in the court dispute.

In summary, Haresh Jogani will give four brothers Rs 2,000 crore.

The real estate dispute, which began 21 years ago, has 18 appeals.

In Southern California, there are 17,000 apartments in the property empire.

A legal dispute involving five brothers of Indian descent resulted in a substantial multibillion-dollar verdict for damages from a US jury.

According to a Bloomberg article, the ruling in a land dispute that dated back 21 years ordered Haresh Jogani to pay his four brothers nearly Rs 2,000 crore in damages and further divide up the interests of their property empire in Southern California. 

Approximately 17,000 apartments totaling billions of dollars are part of the real estate empire.

The 2003 lawsuit was handled by five judges, five generations of attorneys, and 18 appeals before a jury divided the property and awarded billions of dollars. The case was heard in the Los Angeles Superior Court. Claims that Haresh Jogani had broken a long-standing agreement with his siblings sparked the trial. According to sources, the punitive damages hearing is scheduled for Monday and may result in an increase of the current verdict of Rs 2,000 crore.

Some attorneys have also made comparisons between this case and the fictional Victorian-era probate case described in the well-known novel Bleak House by Charles Dickens. With a twist, Jogani v. Jogani is the new Jarndyce v. Jarndyce.

The name "Bleak House" comes from the fact that there was no money at the end of the book. This isn't the case, though. According to the report, one of the lawyers for Chetan and Rajesh Jogani stated, "There are billions here that remain to be distributed."

The Jogani brothers, who originated in Gujarat, amassed wealth through their involvement in the international diamond trade, operating in Europe, Africa, North America, and the Middle East. According to a complaint he filed in 2003, Shashikant Jogani established his business in the gem industry and real estate portfolio after moving to California in 1969.

When real estate saw losses during the crisis in the early 1990s, Shashikant Jogani enlisted his brothers as business partners. According to his complaint, Haresh Jogani terminated the partnership, "forcibly removed" his brother from running the company, and withheld his compensation.

Shashikant Jogani's complaint states that this happened after the company went on a buying binge, resulting in the construction of a portfolio consisting of almost 17,000 housing units.

Haresh Jogani, however, argued that his siblings could not prove they were in a partnership with him in the absence of a formal contract. However, Haresh was deemed to have broken an oral contract by the Los Angeles court. The juror was informed through testimony that oral agreements are common in Gujarati society as well as in the diamond trade.

According to Bloomberg, the legal representative for Shashikant Jogani said that spoken agreements are legally as binding as written ones.

Following many years, multiple appeals, accusations of bias, and charges of "racial animus" made by Haresh Jogani, the jury determined that Shashikant Jogani, 77, is the 50% owner of the real estate partnership and awarded him USD 1.8 billion in first damages.

Source: India Today